Running into the PayPal error message “This card can’t be used with this plan” can be frustrating, especially when you are trying to sign up for a subscription, complete a recurring payment, or unlock a digital service. This issue is more common than most users realize, and it often has straightforward solutions.
What the Error Means
When PayPal displays This card can’t be used with this plan, it means the card you are trying to use is not eligible for the type of payment you are attempting to make. This typically happens during subscription setups, auto-renewals, or recurring billing agreements. PayPal runs several automated checks when a user attempts to link a card to a plan, and if any of the rules fail, the platform blocks the setup to protect the cardholder and the merchant.
Common Reasons the Error Appears
One of the most frequent reasons is that the card issuer has restricted recurring transactions. Not all banks or prepaid card providers allow automatic or subscription charges, and PayPal is required to follow the card issuer’s rules. In many cases, the card is not enabled for international payments or online recurring payments, which also triggers the error.
Another reason is related to PayPal account status or limitations. Newly created accounts, accounts with unverified identities, or accounts flagged for unusual activity may be restricted from adding cards to subscription plans. Sometimes the card being used is already linked to another PayPal account, or the card information does not match the account holder’s details.
Expired or soon-to-expire cards can also cause this message. Even if the card has a valid number, PayPal checks expiration dates before approving recurring billing agreements.
Note that some merchants impose their own restrictions. Certain service providers only accept cards from specific countries or card networks, and PayPal simply enforces the rules set by the merchant.
How to Fix This Error
Start by ensuring your card is active and supports online recurring payments. Many banks can enable or disable subscription permissions through their mobile apps, so checking the card’s online settings is a fast first step. If the feature is restricted, contacting the bank’s customer support often resolves the issue quickly.
Confirm that your PayPal account is fully verified. Verifying your identity, confirming your email, and linking a bank account can sometimes remove hidden limitations. A verified account is less likely to trigger subscription blocks.
Make sure the card information is correct. Even small details like mismatched addresses or old ZIP codes can cause PayPal to reject the card for plan-based payments. Updating your billing information inside PayPal can fix the problem immediately.
Try using a different card if possible. Debit and prepaid cards are the most likely to be restricted by banks, while credit cards generally work more consistently with subscription plans.
If you believe the issue comes from the merchant, contacting their support team can help. Sometimes merchants can manually approve the payment method or provide an alternative subscription link.
When to Contact PayPal Support
If you have verified your card, confirmed that it supports recurring payments, and ensured your PayPal account has no restrictions, but the error still persists, then reaching out to PayPal support is the next logical step. PayPal’s team can check whether your account has internal flags, whether the merchant’s system is sending incorrect signals, or whether your card issuer is rejecting requests in the background. They can also guide you through specific troubleshooting steps tailored to your account.
Do you use PayPal Checkout to accept payments in WordPress? Checkout for PayPal can help.